What’s Your Question?

As a service to our members, Catholics United for the Faith has a Catholic Responses department that’s always available to answer their questions. One particular member sent us three questions last week, and I’ll reprint them below along with my responses. 

(1)  Does the Church have an official answer on the age of the earth in terms of numbers?  I read a couple of things at other sites, but did not seem to find an actual accepted age.  I have been in dialogue with a fallen-away Catholic.

Answer: The Church has no official teaching as to the actual, chronological age of the earth. This points to two important considerations: First, the Church does not consider it her domain to make pronouncements in the area of natural science. Second, and related to this, the Church does not require the faithful to accept that the “days” in the creation account in Genesis are actual, chronological days as we understand the term. Once we say that the faith does not require a strictly literalistic interpretation of the opening chapter of Genesis, we have no basis as a matter exclusively of faith to calculate the age of the earth, and of course modern science is only able to give us estimates and hypotheses.

(2) This may be rather simplistic but here goes:  Why, if we want to teach the layperson exactly between right and wrong according to our Faith, does the Pope speak in such “heavy” terms.  I have read encyclicals, homilies, official responses; etc and find them to be esoteric.  I can get the message most times but it seems very well, esoteric – not designed for the theologically challenged.  In this unintellectual age, we need simple, clear speech for the masses from the Holy See, no?

Answer: That’s a very good question. Of course when we get beyond the basic core (or “kerygma”) of our faith, we get into some very detailed issues, from bioethics to systematic theology to biblical interpretations involving the translation of obscure languages. It’s important for the Pope or Vatican offices to write with precision in encyclicals and other such formal documents so that the faith is never watered down or compromised.

The work of bringing this teaching to the level of people’s understanding is the work of catechesis. This takes place at home, at Catholic schools and religious education programs, at the parish, particularly through homilies that have some substance, and also through our culture, as we take our faith with us into the community. The problem isn’t the Pope speaking over our heads so much as the fact that in recent decades we’ve had a breakdown of Catholic teaching across the board in this country and elsewhere, leading to a decline in our “Catholic literacy.” This is turning around, but we still have a ways to go.

(3) Have you read Love your God with All Your Mind by J.P. Moreland?  It was recommended to me by a Protestant but I am unfamiliar with it. 

Answer: I’ve never read anything by J.P. Moreland. I know he’s a well-respected Protestant author in the area of Christian apologetics. My understanding is that his stuff is on the “heady” side, as he explores the philosophical and intellectual basis of a Christian worldview. Obviously he’s not Catholic, so like C.S. Lewis’ Mere Christianity, his book will only take you so far. Also, given your previous question, perhaps you would prefer somebody who addresses similar subjects not only from a Catholic perspective, but also in more accessible prose. In that regard, I would highly recommend the work of Dr. Peter Kreeft, a former professor of mine who has written dozens of excellent books on related topics.

* * *

Our question-and-answer service, through which we’ve helped tens of thousands of Catholics through the years, depends on the generous financial support of our members and benefactors. Please consider making a donation this Easter season. For information on making a donation online, click here

2 responses

  1. Father DiNoia in the Vatican Congregation for the DOctrine of Faith is a former theology professor mine. I would llike to study the document which was released last year on the interpretation of the word “subsistare”. Please advise as to how to access this.

    Your blog states that you will post this document:

    Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith

    Church on a Mission
    Friday, December 14th, 2007
    The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith has just issued a document entitled “Doctrinal Note on Some Aspects of Evangelization.” The text should be available sometime today and we’ll post a link when that occurs.
    At today’s presentation of the document, Father Joseph Augustine Di Noia, O.P, who serves as CDF undersecretary, said that the document first began […]

    CDF Responds to Questions on the Nature of the Catholic Church
    Tuesday, July 10th, 2007
    The Congregration for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF), the Vatican’s doctrinal office, just issued a document clarfiying the doctrine of the Church on June 29, 2007, the solemnity of Sts. Peter and Paul.
    Important issues addressed in this document include the relation of Vatican II statements to prior Church teaching; the meaning of the word […]

    Thank you.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *